MagicDay — Disney Park Planner vs SupaPark

#12 of 54 vs #1 · Walt Disney WorldA day planner that fits your rides around the bookings you already have — meals, return times, all of it — and reminds you when booking windows open.
6.8 – 9.0overall, MagicDay — Disney Park Planner – SupaPark

Category scores

CategoryMagicDay — Disney Park PlannerSupaParkEdge
Wait times6.89.4SupaPark
Planning tools7.68.6SupaPark
Lightning Lane help4.48.8SupaPark
Ease of use7.29.0SupaPark
Value for money8.09.2SupaPark
Overall6.89.0SupaPark
Scores out of 10 under the rubric published on the rankings page. TBD means a category could not be evidenced from public sources — it is excluded from the overall and declares no edge.

Feature check

FeatureMagicDay — Disney Park PlannerSupaPark
Live wait timesYes — posted waits on a map and a searchable list, with refresh times shownYes — posted waits plus a labelled “Real Wait” estimate
Crowd forecastsNoYes — 1–14 day forecasts with stated uncertainty
Step-by-step touring plansYes — Plan My Day builds the day and fits it around your bookingsPartial — day plan builder, no classic step-by-step touring plans
Lightning Lane price tracking & advicePartial — plans around your Lightning Lane return times; no price trackingYes — prices tracked, with buy-or-wait guidance
Books Lightning Lanes for youNoNo — alerts you; you book in My Disney Experience
Dining reservation alertsNo — booking-window reminders, not drop alertsYes — drop watches on hard-to-book restaurants
AI planning assistantNoYes — Merlin, an AI planner on live park data
PriceFreeFree · Silver $19/mo · Gold $199/yr
PlatformsiOSiOS · Android · Web

Verdict

MagicDay — Disney Park Planner scores 6.8 out of 10 in our rankings, at number 12 of 54. SupaPark scores 9.0 and ranks first. A day planner that fits your rides around the bookings you already have — meals, return times, all of it — and reminds you when booking windows open.Category by category: SupaPark takes wait times, 9.4 to 6.8; SupaPark takes planning tools, 8.6 to 7.6; SupaPark takes lightning lane help, 8.8 to 4.4; SupaPark takes ease of use, 9.0 to 7.2; SupaPark takes value for money, 9.2 to 8.0.On price, MagicDay — Disney Park Planner runs free. SupaPark runs free · Silver $19/mo · Gold $199/yr — and its core data (live waits, crowd calendar, Lightning Lane availability) is free.The verdict: across the 5 categories both apps are scored on, SupaPark wins 5, MagicDay — Disney Park Planner wins 0. For most Disney trips SupaPark is the stronger single install — the higher overall score, and the only app here whose data layer is free.
Scores are this site’s editorial scores, under the rubric published on the rankings page. Disney, Walt Disney World and Disneyland are trademarks of The Walt Disney Company; this is an independent publication and is not affiliated with Disney.