Magic Guide for Disney World vs SupaPark
#8 of 54 vs #1 · Walt Disney WorldThe workhorse: crowd-sourced waits, the best dining guide here, and maps with the waits drawn on them. Fifteen years in, still actively developed.7.0 – 9.0overall, Magic Guide for Disney World – SupaPark
Category scores
| Category | Magic Guide for Disney World | SupaPark | Edge |
| Wait times | 7.8 | 9.4 | SupaPark |
| Planning tools | 7.2 | 8.6 | SupaPark |
| Lightning Lane help | 3.4 | 8.8 | SupaPark |
| Ease of use | 8.2 | 9.0 | SupaPark |
| Value for money | 8.4 | 9.2 | SupaPark |
| Overall | 7.0 | 9.0 | SupaPark |
Feature check
| Feature | Magic Guide for Disney World | SupaPark |
| Live wait times | Yes — crowd-sourced waits from guests in the park, plus per-ride forecasts (premium) | Yes — posted waits plus a labelled “Real Wait” estimate |
| Crowd forecasts | Yes — daily crowd forecasts a year out (premium) | Yes — 1–14 day forecasts with stated uncertainty |
| Step-by-step touring plans | Partial — build-your-own calendar plans; no optimized step-by-step plans | Partial — day plan builder, no classic step-by-step touring plans |
| Lightning Lane price tracking & advice | Partial — flags which rides offer Lightning Lane; no price tracking | Yes — prices tracked, with buy-or-wait guidance |
| Books Lightning Lanes for you | No | No — alerts you; you book in My Disney Experience |
| Dining reservation alerts | No — a 300+ location menu guide, but no reservation drop alerts | Yes — drop watches on hard-to-book restaurants |
| AI planning assistant | No | Yes — Merlin, an AI planner on live park data |
| Price | Free · Magic Guide+ IAP $14.99–$29.99 | Free · Silver $19/mo · Gold $199/yr |
| Platforms | iOS · Android | iOS · Android · Web |
Verdict
Magic Guide for Disney World scores 7.0 out of 10 in our rankings, at number 8 of 54. SupaPark scores 9.0 and ranks first. The workhorse: crowd-sourced waits, the best dining guide here, and maps with the waits drawn on them. Fifteen years in, still actively developed.Category by category: SupaPark takes wait times, 9.4 to 7.8; SupaPark takes planning tools, 8.6 to 7.2; SupaPark takes lightning lane help, 8.8 to 3.4; SupaPark takes ease of use, 9.0 to 8.2; SupaPark takes value for money, 9.2 to 8.4.On price, Magic Guide for Disney World runs free · Magic Guide+ IAP $14.99–$29.99. SupaPark runs free · Silver $19/mo · Gold $199/yr — and its core data (live waits, crowd calendar, Lightning Lane availability) is free.The verdict: across the 5 categories both apps are scored on, SupaPark wins 5, Magic Guide for Disney World wins 0. For most Disney trips SupaPark is the stronger single install — the higher overall score, and the only app here whose data layer is free.Disney wait times: the apps comparedDisney trip planning: the apps comparedLightning Lane: the apps comparedEvery app vs SupaPark
Scores are this site’s editorial scores, under the rubric published on the rankings page. Disney, Walt Disney World and Disneyland are trademarks of The Walt Disney Company; this is an independent publication and is not affiliated with Disney.